Electoral Commission asked to rule on poster that compares mayors to Hitler


Campaigners against an elected mayor for Birmingham may face an Electoral Commission enquiry after criticism of a leaflet that equates the mayoral role with that of fascist dictators.

The leaflet, adorned with an image of a Birmingham street after a German bombing raid in the second world war, says: ‘Brummies have always fought back against disctators. Don’t elect one – vote no!”

Roger Godsiff MP, who leads the ‘Vote No to an Elected Power Freak’ campaign with fellow MP John Hemming, was unapologetic, telling the BBC:

If some of the wannabe candidates and their associated PR advisers, consultants, media reps and lobbyists… have had their feathers ruffled by the leaflet, I’m not particularly concerned.

Supporters of the yes campaign say the poster has dragged the debate into the gutter. John O’Shea, who blogs as PoliticalHack said:

It’s wrong, it’s obscene. It needs to be withdrawn and we need an apology from the no campaign.”

The Chamberlain Files has learned that a complaint has been sent to the Electoral Commission, asking the body to investigate whether the poster breaks any electioneering rules. The Commission oversees the  conduct of campaigns and elections in the UK, but it is unclear whether it has jurisdiction over the mayoral referendum. Local elections are the responsibility of the local authorities, where chief executives such as Birmingham’s Stephen Hughes are returning officers.

However, the letter sent to the commission by a leading member of Birmingham’s business community, says:

This document … uses a photograph of a German blitz on Burford Street, Digbeth in its grotesque attempts to suggest an elected mayor for Birmingham would be as much as dictator as Adolf Hitler.  This is sickening to all Brummies, not least the 2214 … Birmingham citizens who died during that blitz, and their families who are alive today. We require a grown up and civilised debate about localism and the way in which we are governed locally in Birmingham.

Enhanced by Zemanta

4 Comments on “Electoral Commission asked to rule on poster that compares mayors to Hitler”

  1. […] Electoral Commission asked to rule on poster that compares mayors to Hitler (thechamberlainfiles.wordpress.com) Share this:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

  2. Just to be clear – I’m not acting on behalf of any candidate declared or undeclared, nor do I speak for the Yes campaign. I am openly in support of that campaign, but I also want there to be a proper debate about the proposed mayor for Birmingham. There are arguments against it – Les Reid articulated them well during the debate – but the No to an elected power freak campaign is insulting the intelligence of the people of Birmingham, as well as our history.

  3. Tom says:

    John Hemming and co are just idiots. But I never knew they would stoop this low. Nick Clegg should be asked outright what he think of his MP behaving in this disgusting way!

  4. Certainly a very bad taste campaign poster from the ‘No’ brigade, but the leaflet will not be judged to be unlawful or illegal…besides, there are no mayoral elections, as yet!


What's your view?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s